The Original Goodfellas Menu

Popular menu items

NY Style Cheese Pizza

$13.20 +

Grandma Pizza

$24.20 +

Puntanesca

$18.15 +

Pizzas

NY Style Cheese Pizza

$13.20 +

Old World Cheese Pizza

$13.20 +

Vodka Pizza

$18.15 +

Smoking Goodfella

$18.15 +

Caldo E Dolce

$18.15 +

Buffalo Chicken

$18.15 +

White Clam Pie

$18.15 +

Smokin Hots

$18.15 +

Roasted Vegetable

$18.15 +

Pesto Artichoke Tomato

$18.15 +

Tequila Sunrise

$18.15 +

Quattro Formaggi

$18.15 +

Pizza Bianca

$18.15 +

Arugula Bianca

$18.15 +

Porcini Arugula

$18.15 +

Grandma Pizza

$24.20 +

Puntanesca

$18.15 +

Rolls

Chicken Parm

$13.20 +

Vodka Chicken

$13.20 +

Fresh Spinach

$13.20 +

Sausage & Peppers

$13.20 +

Pepperoni

$13.20 +

Calzones

$13.20 +

Appetizers

Goodfella's Buffalo-Style Chicken Wings (6)

$14.85

Garlic Knots

$6.60 +

Homemade Mozzarella 'N Carrozza

$15.95 +

Goodfellas Baked Clams (10)

$18.15 +

Mussels Marinara

$20.35 +

Homemade, Mozzarella, Tomato & Basil

$15.40 +

Stuffed Mushrooms (6)

$13.75 +

Bruschetta

$11.00 +

Octopus Carpaccio

$23.10 +

2 Stuffed Long Hots

$15.95 +

Smoked Burrata

$16.50 +

Fried Zucchini

$13.75 +

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

$19.80 +

Goodfella's Famous Fried Calamari

$18.15 +

Sides

Baby Spinach

$7.70

Broccoli Rabe

$9.90

Meatballs (3)

$13.20

Sausage (2)

$8.80

Rstd Vegetables

$8.80

Italian Heroes

Chicken Parmigiana

$16.50 +

Meatball Parmigiana

$16.50 +

Eggplant Parmigiana

$16.50 +

The Goodfella's Italian Cold Cut Sandwich

$16.50 +

Grilled Chicken Broccoli Rabe

$16.50 +

Grilled Chicken Caesar

$16.50 +

Stuffed Brick Oven Pitas

Grilled Vegetable

$15.40

Chicken Caesar

$15.40

Grilled Chicken Strawberry Wallnut

$15.40

Salads

Strawberry Mesclun Salad

$14.85 +

Goodfella's House Salad

$12.10 +

Caesar Salad

$13.20 +

Baby Arugula Salad

$15.95 +

Soups

Our Famous Lobster Bisque

$9.90

Housemade Minestrone

$7.70

Entrees

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana

$28.60

Bone-In Veal Parmigiana

$37.40

Eggplant Parmigiana

$26.40

Chicken Francese

$27.50

Chicken Marsala

$27.50

Steak & Chops

Filet Mignon 10oz

$44.00

Duck Fat Infused Porkchop

$33.00

New York Strip 16oz

$41.80

Pork Shank Ossobuco

$36.30

Porter House 40oz

$121.00

Fresh Housemade Pasta

Penne Vodka

$20.35 +

Bucatini & Meatballs Or Sausage

$20.35 +

Ravioli (8)

$18.15 +

Four Baked Cheese Rigatoni

$20.35 +

Cacio E Pepe

$19.80 +

Cavatelli

$24.75 +

Lobster Raviolis & Jumbo Shrimp

$37.40 +

Seafood

Shrimp Rhomolus

$30.80

Red Snapper

$31.90

Mediterranean Salmon

$31.90

Mussels Pomodoro

$30.80

Linguini White Clam Sauce

$28.60

Shrimp Marinara

$33.00

Fra Diavolo

$33.00

Frutti Di Mare

$37.40

Shrimp Francese

$33.55

Desserts

Tiramisu

$8.80

NY Cheesecake

$7.70

Pistachio Tartufo

$8.80

Tartufo

$8.80

Toasted Almond

$8.80

Chocolate Cake

$8.80

Limoncello Flute

$8.80

Cannoli

$6.60

Brownie

$8.80

Nutella Calzone

$13.20

Apple Pizza

$19.80

Creme Brulee

$8.80

Drink

Coke

$1.65 +

Diet Coke

$1.65 +

Sprite

$1.65 +

Orange

$1.65

Seltzer

$1.65

Gingerale

$1.65

Snapple

$2.75

San Pellegrino

$8.80

Stewarts

$3.30

Bottled Water

$1.95

The Original Goodfellas

A leading Staten Island restaurant on Grubhub

4029 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10308

(718) 987-2422